Quick Reactions: How is MTG Marvel's Spider-Man Performing?

Magic: The Gathering’s Marvel’s Spider-Man set has officially hit shelves, and reactions are pouring in from players, collectors, and retailers. Released on September 26, 2025, this crossover expansion blends the iconic superhero universe with MTG’s strategic gameplay. But how is it actually performing? Let's dig into some fan reactions, sales numbers, and impact on the game.

Mixed Reactions from the Community

Initial feedback has been polarized, like it is with most Universes Beyond sets. Casual players and fans of Spider-Man are thrilled by the flavorful card designs and the inclusion of characters like Anti-Venom, Miles Morales, Gwenom, and Spectacular Spider-Man. The Extended Art and Borderless variants are especially popular among collectors due to their comic book-esque design and classic art style.

However, competitive players and Limited format enthusiasts have voiced concerns. Many cite shallow card pools, narrow and repetitive mechanics, and underwhelming gameplay. Compared to recent hits like The Lord of the Rings and FINAL FANTASY, Spider-Man’s mechanics feel rushed and less impactful.

Sales Numbers and Collector Frenzy

Despite mixed reviews, the set is generating strong sales, particularly in the high-end market. Collector Boosters are flying off shelves, driven by ultra-rare chase cards like the Textless Cosmic Foil version of The Soul Stone. One such card reportedly sold for over $20,000 on eBay, underscoring the set’s appeal to investors and collectors, garnering the attention of the scalping crowd.

Retailers have noted lower prerelease attendance and cautious spending from budget-conscious players, but premium product sales are keeping the set profitable for Wizards of the Coast.

Impact on MTG and Future Crossovers

Marvel’s Spider-Man marks a significant moment in MTG’s ongoing push into branded crossovers, with more Marvel to come in 2026. While the gameplay may not satisfy every player, the financial success and collector interest suggest that IP-driven sets will continue to be a major part of MTG’s strategy.

The set also introduces the Pick-Two Draft format, a new twist on Limited play that could shape future releases. Whether this innovation sticks or fades will depend on how well it integrates with broader gameplay preferences.

Can MTG's Spider-Man Keep Pace?

Marvel’s Spider-Man is a paradox. It’s a collector’s dream and a competitive player’s dilemma. Its success lies in its visual appeal and brand power, not necessarily in its gameplay depth. For fans of Spider-Man and high-end MTG cards, it’s a thrilling ride. For others, it may be worth waiting for the next set.

With basic product already plateauing, it's hard to tell whether the set will continue to sell or start an early decline. The biggest hope this set has is sadly in the scalping community, who will continue to scoop up collector product to resell at a premium. As long as Wizards gets their money, it is a win in their book.